The rebel yell
The Israeli response to Chanukah described earlier is interesting. Is your image of Jews really one of powerful rebels or something different? In many ways, the celebration of Chanukah is a celebration of this rebellion and an early example of a struggle for religious freedom. A rather American response to the Chanukah story can be seen in the following quote, taken from a textbook designed to help American educators teach about Chanukah.
"Chanukah was the first struggle for religious freedom in the history of the world. It affirms the Universal truth that the only effective answer to oppression is to fight for and defend the very values and principles which that oppression tries to suppress".
- What do you think of this statement. Are there values for which you feel it s worth getting up and fighting for? Is this always the best response to oppression? One way to explore this response to Chanukah is to write the following time line on the board and discuss and compare each of the cases.
1220 BCE Jews leave Egypt
165 BCE Maccabean Revolt
1215 CE The Magna Carta
1776 CE American Revolution
1789 CE French Revolution
What do all these cases have in common? Does Chanukah really fit in well with the others? Are there any other cases you would like to add to this time line? What title would you give it?
Next Page